Skip to content

Players union approves of Thunder’s Josh Huestis arrangement

Jul 24, 2014, 6:30 PM EDT

Josh Huestis, Troy Weaver Josh Huestis, Troy Weaver

The Thunder and Josh Huestis have agreed for the No. 29 pick to turn down his rookie-scale NBA contract and play on a D-League contract next season, an arrangement made before the draft.

The deal is good for the Thunder, who won’t have to pay Huestis this year and now could have five years to develop him before free agency.

And it’s good for Huestis, who probably wouldn’t have been picked in the first round without this promise and is presumably now line for a rookie-scale deal in a year.

There’s only one catch.

NBA by-laws state:

Prior to the annual NBA Draft, Members may have preliminary discussions with players eligible for the Draft, but may not discuss the matter of compensation.

As I’ve covered, I can’t even imagine a workaround to the pre-draft negotiations that would technically avoid compensation discussion, let alone adhere to the spirit of the rule.

As a result, I thought the the National Basketball Players Association would have a big problem with Oklahoma City’s maneuvering. After all, the Thunder prevented another player from getting that rookie-scale contract by drafting Huestis and not giving it to him, a set of events that likely would not have occurred without pre-draft compensation talks.

Alas, the players union doesn’t find this problematic.

Zach Lowe of Grantland:

The union actually views the Huestis move as an example of player empowerment that could have major long-term implications. “This is an example of the player flipping the script,” says Ron Klempner, the interim executive director of the union. “The player essentially drafted his team.”

I agree that Huestis has exercised a level of control rarely exerted by players, and that’s good for him.

But the players union should not allow players to do whatever they want when their personal interests adversely affect other players. To the union’s credit, it has successfully bargained for many such restrictions.

The CBA prevents players from making less than a minimum salary. It prevents players from taking extreme pay decreases during a multi-year contract. It prevents players from re-negotiating contracts to reduce the compensation.

As a union, the NBPA restricts players in certain situations in order to protect players as a whole. Why not do that here?

If it seems there’s more to this situation, there is.

Lowe:

The deal is proof that teams have an ambivalent relationship with low-first-round picks, since Oklahoma City is dodging the rookie scale here, Klempner says. But that can cut both ways. “The rookie wage scale was management-imposed,” he says. “Players have always been in favor of more open negotiation for rookies. Maybe [Huestis] will lead to a full reconsideration of the rookie wage scale.”

In other words: If teams want wiggle room with someone picked in the late 20s, then they should grant that same negotiating wiggle room for Anthony Davis and Andrew Wiggins. The NBA has been down that road before, and would fight hard against any removal of the rookie scale, but Klempner has a point.

Before the NBA instituted the rookie scale, high draft picks like Glenn Robinson and Larry Johnson held out for huge contracts. Of course, the union would like to expand salary for all players, including rookies, and this could be an opening. Can you imagine how much Andrew Wiggins and Jabari Parker would make if they weren’t slotted into set salary ranges?

However, I believe Klempner is making a big miscalculation for two reasons.

1. I doubt the NBA uses the Huestis case as precedent for loosening the restrictions on first-round picks. The league fought for a rookie scale for a reason, and it won’t walk it back now. Even if it means paying picks like Huestis less, the top selections would more than make up for it. Open negotiations for draft picks is a money loser for the owners.

2. The veterans who comprise the NBPA wouldn’t go for it. Every member of the union has already gone through the draft, so they won’t vote to have their wages implicitly cut in order to pay future rookies. Veterans getting paid less than new draft picks was a big point of contention in the Glenn Robinson/Larry Johnson era, and even if such an arrangement helped players collectively, it doesn’t help voting players (i.e., players already in the league/union) at all.

It seems as if the NBPA will let the Thunder slide in pursuit of a bigger goal – freer negotiations for first-round picks – it won’t achieve. Without the union pushing, I doubt the NBA will investigate whether Oklahoma City violated the by-law.

So, I guess the Thunder are mostly in the clear to watch Huestis get D-League compensation due to their pre-draft discussions.

Latest Posts
  1. PBT Extra matchup to watch: Can Toronto keep Paul Pierce quiet on the court?

    Apr 21, 2015, 12:14 AM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznptrkyze4nmfkytlhmjnjodc4mjk4mgq0nzixowuwndg2 AP

    Pierce’s comments made him unpopular north of the border, but his play should bother the Raptors more.

  2. PBT Extra matchup to watch: Dallas has to find a way to deal with Dwight Howard

    Apr 20, 2015, 9:59 PM EDT

    Tyson Chandler, Dirk Nowitzki, Dwight Howard Tyson Chandler, Dirk Nowitzki, Dwight Howard

    He was simply the most dominant player in Game 1 of the Mavericks vs. Rockets series.

  3. Man arrested after fight over who is better, Michael Jordan or LeBron James

    Apr 20, 2015, 8:50 PM EDT

    Miami Heat v Charlotte Bobcats - Game Four Getty Images

    I could try to use logic and suggest that discussing the complete legacy of Jordan with the incomplete legacy of James is a fool’s errand. But this is the Internet, logic is not always welcome.

  4. PBT Extra matchup to watch: Marcus Smart needs to take on Kyrie Irving challenge

    Apr 20, 2015, 7:50 PM EDT

    Kyrie Irving Kyrie Irving

    What you want to see as a Boston fan is Smart embrace the challenge.

  5. PBT Extra matchup to watch: Pelican guards need to stay with Curry, Thompson

    Apr 20, 2015, 5:32 PM EDT

    New Orleans Pelicans v Golden State Warriors - Game One New Orleans Pelicans v Golden State Warriors - Game One

    Also, Tyreke Evans is a game-time decision after his injury in the playoff opener.

  6. Clippers will rebrand this summer, new potential logos leaked

    Apr 20, 2015, 4:06 PM EDT

    Screen-shot-2015-04-17-at-10.35.11-PM

    The Clippers need a rebranding, but the leaked images are not winning over new fans.

  7. Report: One Trail Blazers player gives LaMarcus Aldridge just 50-50 chance of re-signing

    Apr 20, 2015, 11:57 AM EDT

    Portland Trail Blazers v Memphis Grizzlies - Game One Getty Images

    And he’s not the only Portland player worried about Aldridge leaving

Featured video

Can Michael Carter-Williams slow Derrick Rose?
Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. D. Rose (5453)
  2. C. Parsons (5126)
  3. K. Durant (4983)
  4. P. George (4927)
  5. M. Conley (4725)
  1. T. Splitter (4581)
  2. L. James (4414)
  3. D. Lee (4291)
  4. K. Bryant (4254)
  5. S. Curry (4199)