Skip to content

Boston Globe’s Gary Washburn defends his lone vote for ‘Melo for MVP

May 6, 2013, 8:44 AM EDT

New York Knicks v Miami Heat Getty Images

LeBron James received 120 of the 121 first place votes for MVP — he was one vote short of being the first ever unanimous pick.

The person who cast the lone dissenting vote was the very good, very well respected NBA writer for the Boston Globe Gary Washburn, who defended his vote Monday in the paper.

Secondly, this isn’t the Best Player in the Game award, it’s the Most Valuable Player award, and I think what Anthony accomplished this season was worthy of my vote. He led the Knicks to their first division title in 19 years.

That’s a long time ago.

Anthony led the league in scoring average and basically carried an old Knicks team to the No. 2 seed in the Eastern Conference. Amar’e Stoudemire missed most of the season with knee issues, Raymond Felton missed six weeks, and Tyson Chandler dealt with nagging injuries, leaving Anthony, J.R. Smith, and a bunch of lottery picks from the mid-1990s to win 54 games and beat the Miami Heat three times.

This is a fair argument, and while not one I fully agree with he certainly is within his bounds to make it and cast that vote. It’s not like Washburn voted for J.J. Hickson or something, Anthony came in third and was a legitimate MVP candidate. Frankly, I’d rather hear the explanation of the nine voters who left Anthony out of their top five completely.

And the league intentionally does not define MVP for the voters — you can vote for the best player in the game, the guy you think who was most important to his team, the best player on the best team, or however else you wish to define most valuable. I think for most voters this definition is more art than science — they know what the MVP is when they see it. And it’s a combination of all those definitions.

The idea that the league or anyone else didn’t want LeBron to be unanimous is bunk — for one Washburn is not the kind of guy swayed by that stuff. He voted his conscience.

I think LeBron deserved it for a tremendous season lifting a good team to the best record in the NBA, to a level where they won 27 in a row and were dominant. To me Anthony had his best season ever, however, and will agree that without him this Knicks roster is in a lot of trouble this past season. And remember, the votes are for the regular season — Anthony’s playoff struggles (against defenses overloaded to stop him) do not matter in the voting.

Just like people often say with politics, I don’t agree with Washburn’s vote but I’ll defend his right to cast it.

But this makes you wonder about past voting — Michael Jordan was never unanimous? Kareem Abdul-Jabbar? Wilt Chamberlain? Washburn is not Fred Hickman (the broadcaster’s one vote in 2000 cost Shaquille O’Neal a unanimous win, Hickman voted for Allen Iverson) he was a guy voting what he saw and believed.

And he had the courage to defend it publicly. Good on him. Now we can all move on to the games and things that really matter in basketball.

Latest Posts
  1. Pero Antic commits flagrant foul on LeBron James (VIDEO)

    May 22, 2015, 9:30 PM EDT

    Cleveland Cavaliers v Atlanta Hawks - Game One Getty Images

    Ruled a flagrant, which was probably the correct call under the circumstances.

  2. Lakers not planning on trading the No. 2 pick in this year’s draft

    May 22, 2015, 8:30 PM EDT

    Mitch Kupchak AP

    GM Mitch Kupchak: “It looks as though we’ll use our pick this year.”

  3. Kyrie Irving out for Game 2 vs. Hawks

    May 22, 2015, 7:38 PM EDT

    Miami Heat v Cleveland Cavaliers Getty Images

    Irving is dealing with a knee injury.

  4. Kobe Bryant tries to explain Stephen Curry with a riddle

    May 22, 2015, 7:15 PM EDT

    Los Angeles Lakers v Golden State Warriors Getty Images

    Explaining Stephen Curry’s game is just not that easy.

  5. Clippers’ Dahntay Jones: There’s no rift between Chris Paul, DeAndre Jordan

    May 22, 2015, 6:49 PM EDT

    Denver Nuggets v Los Angeles Clippers Getty Images

    Did they disagree? Sure. Was there a rift… depends on who you ask.

  6. Report: Clippers, other teams have made Summer League offers to Royce White

    May 22, 2015, 4:15 PM EDT

    Royce White AP

    Summer League is a perfect place for giving White another look.

  7. Report: Lakers have ‘big-time’ interest in signing DeMarre Carroll, Celtics and Pistons also in pursuit

    May 22, 2015, 2:45 PM EDT

    Los Angeles Lakers v Atlanta Hawks Getty Images

    Would they pay him the $15 million per season one NBA executive estimated the Hawks forward could get in free agency?

  8. Kyrie Irving misses shootaround, questionable for Game 2

    May 22, 2015, 10:25 AM EDT

    Cleveland Cavaliers v Atlanta Hawks - Game One Getty Images

    Is his injury more serious than previously thought?

  9. Kyrie Irving: ‘I just don’t have it right now’

    May 22, 2015, 9:10 AM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznpwu5mtvkywy4odfmzjk4yjfkyjm1m2rhymzizmyzy2m3 AP

    Cavaliers will keep leaning on injured point guard – at least to some degree – anyway

  10. Jerry West took Harrison Barnes under his wing, mentored him like he did Kobe

    May 22, 2015, 8:31 AM EDT

    Houston Rockets v Golden State Warriors - Game Two Getty Images

    Barnes all but begged for the chance for a couple years.

Featured video

Small ball lineup propelled Warriors to Game 1 win
Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. K. Irving (6663)
  2. K. Love (5651)
  3. P. Beverley (5000)
  4. D. Howard (4611)
  5. S. Curry (4418)
  1. K. Durant (3934)
  2. M. Speights (3851)
  3. K. Bryant (3795)
  4. L. James (3744)
  5. D. Carroll (3697)