Skip to content

LeBron says rings alone don’t define a player’s career

Feb 16, 2013, 11:30 AM EST

Miami Heat's James listens to a question during media availability for the NBA All-Star basketball game in Houston Reuters

HOUSTON — The argument has been the fallback of Kobe Bryant defenders (he needs defenders?) for years. That it’s about the rings, that’s what makes him better than his peers.

Michael Jordan himself even went there in picking Kobe over LeBron James in a recent interview, saying the five-to-one title disparity decided it.

LeBron was asked about that Friday in Houston for the All-Star Game and gave a smart but kind of long answer. That answer has been reduced by many to a simple sound bite of “rings don’t define me” and people have run with that. Welcome to the modern media (and we have certainly played that game before here).

But LeBron’s full quote makes more valid points — it’s more than just rings.

“That’s his own opinion,” James said of Jordan’s comments. “At the end of the day, rings don’t always define someone’s career. If that was the case, then I would sit up here and say I would take (Celtics legend Bill) Russell over Jordan. I wouldn’t. I wouldn’t take Russell over Jordan. Russell has 11 rings, Jordan has six. Take, I don’t know, Robert Horry over Kobe. I wouldn’t do that. It’s your own personal opinion. Rings do not define a person’s career….

“You look at a guy (Jordan era Bulls backup) Jud Buechler, he has multiple rings, Charles Barkley does not have one ring. He’s not better than Charles Barkley. Patrick Ewing is one of the greatest of all time, Reggie Miller is one of the greatest of all time. Sometimes it’s about the situation you’re in, the team you’re in and it’s about timing as well.”

He’s not wrong. But the truth as always lies somewhere in the middle — Barkley and Ewing will forever in part be defined as great players who could not get over the hump. That doesn’t mean they were not legends and do not belong in the Hall of Fame, they unquestionably do.

But rings are still part of the equation. If LeBron’s career ends with just one ring, will we not look back at that as wasted potential and opportunity lost? Of course. But right now we don’t know how many rings LeBron will end his career with.

The problem with comparing Kobe and LeBron is part situation (Kobe landed on a team close to winning titles, LeBron) and part how they adapted and dealt with that. And those are not questions we can fully answer for either of them yet, both are still elite franchise players in the game. Both have a shot at more rings in the coming few years. We can’t fully judge Kobe and LeBron for at least another decade.

Or, we could just sit back, enjoy the moment and say that we are blessed to get to see two of the all-time NBA greats playing at their peak and not try to rank them. We could just savor the moment. That may be the best option of all.

Latest Posts
  1. Derrick Rose scheduled for surgery Friday, will have all or part of meniscus removed

    Feb 26, 2015, 5:45 PM EST

    Derrick Rose Derrick Rose

    He is having all or part of the meniscus removed, which makes for a faster recovery.

  2. Reports: Kings’ Darren Collison to have surgery, likely done for season

    Feb 26, 2015, 5:00 PM EST

    Golden State Warriors v Sacramento Kings Getty Images

    While in theory he could return for a few games, in practice that’s not going to happen.

  3. Heat sign Michael Beasley to 10-day contract

    Feb 26, 2015, 1:11 PM EST

    San Antonio Spurs v Miami Heat - 2014 NBA Finals Game Three Getty Images

    This will be Beasley’s third stint with Miami

  4. Would Rajon Rondo leave the Mavericks for the Lakers?

    Feb 26, 2015, 12:29 PM EST

    Los Angeles Lakers v Dallas Mavericks Getty Images

    Reports emerging Rondo ‘unlikely’ to re-sign with Dallas

  5. This is the fear: Is Derrick Rose on his way to the Penny Hardaway, Bill Walton club?

    Feb 26, 2015, 11:12 AM EST

    Chicago Bulls' Derrick Rose waits for the start of a media interview at the start of the team's training camp at the Berto Arena in Chicago, Illinois Reuters

    It’s too early to say with Rose what hs legacy will be.

  6. Jusuf Nurkic gets most-polite technical foul (video)

    Feb 26, 2015, 9:08 AM EST

    Phoenix Suns v Denver Nuggets Getty Images

    Nuggets center just handed ball to Markieff Morris

  7. Frustrated DeMarcus Cousins takes out anger kicking chair (VIDEO)

    Feb 26, 2015, 1:42 AM EST

    Memphis Grizzlies v Sacramento Kings Getty Images

    Cousins tried to contain his anger and did… until the folding chair provoked him.

  8. Michael Carter-Williams believes he wouldn’t have been traded from Sixers if it was up to his head coach

    Feb 25, 2015, 10:00 PM EST

    Philadelphia 76ers v Milwaukee Bucks Getty Images

    Carter-Williams was sent to the Bucks in a deadline day deal, but believes he’d still be with the Sixers if Brett Brown was calling the shots.

  9. WATCH: Kevin Garnett introduced in Timberwolves return

    Feb 25, 2015, 9:00 PM EST

    Kevin Garnett AP

    Emotional night for fans in Minnesota.

Featured video

Is Derrick Rose the next Penny Hardaway?
Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. M. Carter-Williams (8227)
  2. K. Durant (8116)
  3. C. Bosh (7953)
  4. D. Howard (7243)
  5. S. Curry (6853)
  1. P. George (6807)
  2. D. Rose (6654)
  3. A. Davis (6415)
  4. B. Beal (6191)
  5. I. Canaan (5780)