Skip to content

NBA Free Agency: The final chance for Vince Carter’s redemption

Dec 4, 2011, 10:56 PM EDT

vince-carter-suns Getty Images

At the 2000 NBA All-Star Game, Vince Carter put in one of the most prolific, maybe the single best performances in NBA history.

In the 2000 summer Olympics, Vince Carter dunked over Frederic Weis in arguably the most famous posterization of all time.

And in the early to mid-2000’s, Carter put together one of the best runs in New Jersey Nets history alongside Jason Kidd and Richard Jefferson (shoutout to Kerry Kittles).

Other than that, Vince Carter has been a model of disappointment for fans and executives. Which is bizarre since he is simultaneously one of the top 40 best players of the past decade. You can make a pretty good argument for him to be top 20 and if you got top 15, you’re not high. Top ten and things get a little smokey, but the point is the same.

In Orlando, it was supposed to be his chance to make the difference, to be the final piece. He didn’t need to be the man, he just needed to be Vince Carter Great, which is a very specific brand of Great at his age. And yet, the same issues that have plagued him and lead to mockery (easily susceptible to injury, questionable heart, failure to deliver in the biggest moments, airballing free throws) tormented him. He was traded to the Phoenix Suns in essentially a combination deal for Hedo Turkoglu and Gilbert Arenas for crying out loud (the Arenas-for-Lewis deal was separate but wouldn’t have occurred without the Phoenix deal for Carter).

So there it is. More injuries, more questions, more vulnerability, more jokes, despite an arguable Hall of Fame career if a few more things had gone his way. His 2006-2007 season? He played 82 games. And the list of players who scored 24 points and a 21 PER? It includes players like Dwyane Wade, David Robinson, Larry Bird, and Oscar Robinson.

But he never made the difference and the way he bailed on Toronto and the way his time ended in so many places will haunt his legacy.

But he gets one more shot.


Vince Carter isn’t a free agent yet, but sources close to the situation say the eight-time All-Star will be thrust onto the open market shortly after the end of the lockout.

Based on an amendment in his contract obtained by, Carter must be waived by the Phoenix Suns within 72 hours of the official start of free agency or his $18 million salary for the 2011-12 season becomes fully guaranteed.

The Suns, sources said, have already decided to waive Carter within that window.

The Suns and Carter amended the contract in June to delay the guaranteed-salary date in Carter’s final contract year until after the lockout ended. Waiving Carter inside the first 72 hours after the league’s schedule start of free agency Friday means that Phoenix would only have to pay $4 million to Carter and likely ensure that the Suns avoid luxury-tax territory this season even after trying to complete the re-signing of Grant Hill and moves with other potential free agents.

via Sources: Phoenix Suns to cut Vince Carter when lockout ends – ESPN.

Carter will hit the open market. The Suns and Carter restructured his contract to help both sides out in the face of the lockout. This move was expected for months. And when he does, he’s the kind of player that can help a team win a title. “Right, like the Magic?” you say. But hear me out.

He’ll never again be the difference maker. Running the pick and roll is not a strength (ask Dwight Howard). If he’s going to make a difference, it’s going to be as a spot-up shooter and the guy who pump-fakes and hits the mid-range J. But there are simply not many guys with his ability to blend into an offense if he’s not expected to create. That’s the biggest issue with Carter at this point, he can’t create and he can’t give heavy minutes. But in limited minutes, off the bench for a stocked team, he provides enough to force away double teams. The Heat are an obvious target. But then so are the Bulls. You have to double Derrick Rose. It’s a necessity like breathing. But if you do so and he kicks out to Carter, and you do manage to recover to challenge on the perimeter, Carter is one of the few players who can pump fake and drive. He can make the plays few players can, even at his age with his injuries. Limited minutes will reduce his workload. And being a glue guy? It’s hard to fine anyone in the league who will speak badly for Carter as a teammate. Fans may hate him, but players love him, even if some may question his intensity.

He shot 42% from the field in Phoenix. Pretty bad. 36% from the arc. Not great. But it’s simply unlikely that with a better role, in a better system, with fewer expectations, he can’t be a difference maker. There’s a chance here. Carter can redeem himself, redefine his legacy.

It’s Carter’s last chance. We’ll see if the story that began with a prolific dunker gets a much-needed full-circle to greatness.


  1. cosanostra71 - Dec 4, 2011 at 11:19 PM

    Man, Vince Carter used to be on top of the world, it’s almost kind of strange to see him talked about in such terms. You almost want to feel bad for the guy, but then you remember him admitting to tanking in TO. His HOF candidacy will be an interesting affair for sure.

    • chargerdillon - Dec 5, 2011 at 12:31 AM

      Make no mistake about it, there is no Hall of Fame candidacy, there never was, there never will be. He has one or two highlights where he dunked over a 7 footer with no skills, that’s about it.

      I can think of about 20 guys with half his skill that deserve the HOF more than him. Part of that measure should be heart.

  2. qball82 - Dec 5, 2011 at 12:35 AM

    “And in the early to mid-2000′s, Carter put together one of the best runs in New Jersey Nets history alongside Jason Kidd and Richard Jefferson (shoutout to Kerry Kittles).”
    Man, this writer needs to do a little research. Vince Carter had nothing to do with the NJ Nets teams that made the finals two years in a row.

  3. seattlesuperchronic - Dec 5, 2011 at 6:31 AM


    How do you measure”heart”? I’ve never seen a “heart” stat on the back of a basketball card. That’s all a bunch of mumbo jumbo.

  4. thebigkahuna23 - Dec 5, 2011 at 10:51 AM

    Carter has scored over 20,000 points in his career. I think he’s in the top 20 all time. And besides that the hall of fame isn’t just about numbers. It’s also contributions to the game. He put a ton of fans in the seats and sold tons of merchandise with his name on it. And while yes he never was a cult player, he did a lot to expand the game’s viewership with his high flying playing style.

  5. borderline1988 - Dec 5, 2011 at 2:02 PM

    Top 20 all time?
    I hope you’re joking.
    VC is barely top 100 of all time (i don’t actually have enough basketball knowledge to pick the top 100 lol).

    VC is the greatest dunker of all time. Plain and simple. In terms of making contributions to his team in the context of winning games, not even close. He was never a top tier player, except for maybe 1 or 2 seasons in Toronto.
    It’s unfortunate because skills-wise, he is one of the best ever. He looked like a young Kobe at first…very good shooter with range, explosive ability to get to the rim, and great handles and moves.

    But the guy bailed out on his team, and his conditioning got worse every year. Most players build muscle mass as they get into their mid-twenties and beyond. Vince Carter actually became more flabby with every passing year in the NBA. Look at pictures of him in the early 2000’s – it’s remarkable how good he looked.
    The blogger mentioned Richard Jefferson – Carter and Jefferson’s career numbers are actually not that far off each other…Carter may have been more popular or had some better individual seasons.
    Or Antoine Walker.

    The guy can dunk. That doesn’t make him a HOFer. Isn’t there some dude from Turkey who can throw down some crazy dunks also?

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. D. Rose (2649)
  2. K. Irving (2037)
  3. A. Davis (1739)
  4. K. Bryant (1554)
  5. L. James (1532)
  1. T. Thompson (1249)
  2. K. Durant (1228)
  3. B. Jennings (1157)
  4. J. Clarkson (1086)
  5. G. Davis (1008)