Skip to content

Winderman: Stoudemire vs. Bosh moves from free agency to Madison Square Garden

Dec 16, 2010, 12:17 PM EDT

665671776

We’re not sure if Friday’s Heat-Knicks game will match Wednesday’s Celtics-Knicks for drama.

But the matchup already has presented Miami and New York with a win-win situation.

The Knicks have their singular star in Amare Stoudemire.

The Heat have their complete complement in Chris Bosh.

Although this will be the first time the power forwards cross paths this season, they essentially were interchangeable parts during the free-agency process.

In fact, at last season’s trading deadline, the Heat made a huge push for Stoudemire, going as far as to propose a three-team deal that would have landed Carlos Boozer as a temporary replacement part for Stoudemire in Phoenix.

Then, this past July, Bosh and Stoudemire essentially were mix-and-match pieces for the Knicks, who made pitches to each during the opening days of free agency.

The Knicks ultimately landed Stoudemire because they were willing to go all-in earlier than Pat Riley. Riley, by contrast, knew that LeBron James wanted Bosh, and that meant waiting for Bosh, even as Stoudemire slipped off the table.

In the end, each team got what it needed.

For years, Stoudemire bristled about being denied the opportunity to be the focus in Phoenix. If it wasn’t Steve Nash being lauded for his passing, it was Shawn Marion being praised for his finishing. What Stoudemire craved was his name at the top of the marquee. He has that in New York. He is Patrick Ewing, albeit far more beloved at this moment.

Bosh, by contrast, was that exact type of singular focus in Toronto for seven seasons, the be-all, do-all presence required to handle the heavy lifting. It became an obligation more onerous than Canadian taxes. In Miami, he is a willing assistant, as much the frontrunner for Third Wheel of the Year as Stoudemire is for MVP.

And Stoudemire very much has the look of a Most Valuable Player. The red lights on the scorers’ table and around the backboard might have denied him three points at the end of Wednesday’s game against the Celtics, but the shot itself only further endeared him to those looking for a hoops hero at 33rd and 8th.

No less than LeBron has Amare at the top of his MVP ballot. There is no jealousy there, even as James stands in line for a three-peat for that very hardware.

And there is no jealousy from Bosh, who essentially stands as the Heat’s equivalent of Danilo Gallinari, functional third option.

“I was just looking at the situation for me,” Bosh said of his free-agent deliberations. “Of course you’re aware of what other players are doing and what they’re thinking, because it’s always on the TV, it was always on the TV every day at that point.

“But with us playing the same positions, I knew it was either him somewhere or me somewhere. And I just wanted to be in the best situation possible. And I’m a lucky guy. I’m here now.”

Friday, though, Bosh will be there, at the Garden, competing head-to-head with Stoudemire, just as he did during those opening days of July.

But while the positions are the same, the roles couldn’t be more different, one currently the NBA’s leading man, the king of the city, the other a supporting actor enjoying the role, and roll, of his career.

Ira Winderman writes regularly for NBCSports.com and covers the Heat and the NBA for the South Florida Sun-Sentinel. You can follow him on Twitter at http://twitter.com/IraHeatBeat.

  1. gnyj85 - Dec 16, 2010 at 12:54 PM

    whoa whoa…lets give it some time before we start comparing A’mare with my man Pat Ewing. As for this game on Friday, A’mare is going to beast that Avatar-looking MF for another 30+.

    • downtowndanny - Dec 17, 2010 at 1:07 AM

      true dat!

  2. trueballs - Dec 16, 2010 at 2:06 PM

    yes he probably will score more than Bosh…and will take more FG attempts…and will probably give up 50 pts at the rim…

  3. d57fan - Dec 16, 2010 at 4:46 PM

    Amare’s getting $100 mil to be the MAN and Bosh is getting $100 mil to be the THIRD man…Take a look at Bosh’s (non) defense when HE was “the man” in Toronto..didn’t get to be the worst defensive team in the league by mistake…he led by (rupaul) non-example and didn’t make a single player on the Raptors better..unlike Wade, LeBron and now, clearly Amare.

    Watch Bosh against Boston…Toronto had to lose him to win their first game against him….at least Amare will punish them….remember this: Toronto (with Bosh) lost a game to Boston last year when the Celtics were WITHOUT Garnett, Pierce and Rondo!
    …nice he gets to bask in reflected glory, but make no mistake Bosh is NOT a superstar, he is a third man…..

  4. downtowndanny - Dec 17, 2010 at 1:13 AM

    Amare is definitely going to house Bosh, but……..who’s going to stop the other two? You can’t out run them, transition is their game. Those 3′s need to be falling for the Knicks tonight, this should be a good game…..

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Wizards playing spoiler in East
Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. A. Jefferson (3505)
  2. K. Durant (2985)
  3. L. James (2917)
  4. D. Wade (2840)
  5. D. Rose (2740)
  1. J. Noah (2618)
  2. D. Howard (2508)
  3. K. Bryant (2496)
  4. A. Bogut (2337)
  5. P. George (2249)