Skip to content

Trying to reassemble the Knicks

Nov 15, 2010, 4:05 PM EDT

Portland Trail Blazers v New York Knicks Getty Images

It was supposed to be different. It really was. With the roster expunged of the mess outside of Wilson Chandler who is still serviceable and Eddy Curry who at least keeps the bench firmly weighted to the ground, things were supposed to be different for the New York Knicks. They had a superstar in Amar’e Stoudemire, a winning coach in Mike D’Antoni that had made the mess win an underwhelming but decent number of games, and the GM at the top to get them the moves for the next level.

It was supposed to be different, but it’s not.

There they sit, at 3-7, the eleventh best team in the Eastern Conference, losing to the Timberwolves before a loss to the Rockets put them on a five-game skid. Amar’e Stoudemire is blasting the team. It’s an abject disaster ten games in, as much as a ten game sample can constitute a disaster.

Here’s where I’m supposed to talk about how Mike D’Antoni’s defense once again proves that his run and gun style can’t win in the NBA. I’m supposed to discuss how soft the Knicks are, and how it’s only a matter of time for this team to fall apart like all the others. According to script I need to throw out cliches about toughness and determination and the chemical makeup of champions. That’s the standard sportswriter script. Good news, though: I hate stuff like that.

Thing is, it’s not the defense. Kind of.

If you look at the Knicks they’re currently 14th in defensive efficiency. That’s about four spots outside of good, and it’s a solid six outside of bad, and about 11 outside of where most people tend to think of them, which is “terrible.” So, no, they are not defensive stalwarts, but they’re also not sieves for you to plunge the knife through. And lest you think that those estimated figures don’t reflect real world results, Synergy Sports has the Knicks giving up an average of 1052 points on 1118 possessions for an average of .94 points per possession allowed, which is 18th in the league. That’s not good, obviously, but it’s also not bad. The Knicks are also average to good in transition, isolation, post-up, and pick and roll defense. They’re really only suffering in spot-ups. So they don’t close out well but it also means teams are simply shooting really well in those situations (51.5% eFG compared to 42.3% FG% which means a lot of threes). The Knicks’ defense isn’t the problem.

Like I said, kind of.

In the span of two weeks, the Knicks gave up 24 assists to Rajon Rondo and 31 rebounds to Kevin Love. Those aren’t just statistical outliers, they’re gigantic spikes through the roof of the chart. But we’re not talking Earl Boykins scoring 42 or Andrea Bargnani rebounding 25 times, things which you simply can’t predict. The Knicks take good players with phenomenal individual skills and turn their production into some sort of nuclear, “TMNT-ooze” like monster version of it. It’s stunning and bizarre and yet wholly predictable.

Meanwhile, the rebounding, which you’d assume sucks, doesn’t. They have a zero differential in offensive rebound rate produced and allowed. So, it’s not the defense. And it’s not the rebounding. And it’s partially psychotic outliers, but not totally. So what is it?

The answer, of course is the offense. Which is wholly dysfunctional. Amar’e Stoudemire not having terrific numbers every night, Raymond Felton very much not looking like a point guard, an early shooting slump from Danilo Galinari, and below average PERs from every bench player. The Knicks can’t function on offense, and that’s why they’re losing.

Sure, chemistry is off. Sure, the formula hasn’t come together. But it’s not failing in the way you’re expecting. And if we’re giving Miami some time to get it together, maybe we should do the same for New York. Oh, wait, I forgot, we’re not doing that because everyone hates them. Got it.

Latest Posts
  1. World Cup Day 1 roundup: Brazil with big win, Andray Blatche puts on a show

    Aug 31, 2014, 12:45 AM EDT

    Raul Togni Neto, Nicolas Batum Raul Togni Neto, Nicolas Batum

    Andray Blatche had 28 points and 12 rebounds for the Philippines, and they still lost.

  2. Manu Ginobili gets statue of himself in Argentina

    Aug 30, 2014, 9:30 PM EDT

    Detroit Pistons v San Antonio Spurs Getty Images

    The statue is in Buenos Aires, in case you were looking to travel to get your picture with it.

  3. Brook Lopez confident he’ll be better than ever

    Aug 30, 2014, 8:00 PM EDT

    That’s a higher bar than most realize

  4. USA cruises past Finland in World Cup opener, 114-55

    Aug 30, 2014, 7:00 PM EDT

    Anthony Davis, Teemu Rannikko Anthony Davis, Teemu Rannikko

    Klay Thompson scored 18 points and Anthony Davis had 17 points on the night. Finland had great fans, though.

  5. Nik Stauskas makes 15 consecutive 3-pointers in 47 seconds (video)

    Aug 30, 2014, 6:30 PM EDT

    2014 NBA Rookie Photo Shoot Getty Images

    Kings rookie rookie honing his 3-point Shootout skills

  6. John Calipari on Anthony Davis: “In five years, he could be the best player in the NBA”

    Aug 30, 2014, 5:00 PM EDT

    Fa14_BB_WBF_Images_Ash_ANTHONY_DAVIS_2_32057

    Will Davis be better than LeBron and Durant in five years? I’ll say this — he’ll be on that level.

  7. 76ers second rounder Jordan McRae signs in Australia

    Aug 30, 2014, 2:00 PM EDT

    Jordan McRae Jordan McRae

    Former Tennessee guard, drafted No. 58, will help Philadelphia tank from afar

  8. Goran Dragic’s brother, Zoran, getting interest from Pacers

    Aug 30, 2014, 12:30 PM EDT

    BASKET-EURO-2013-SLO-FRA BASKET-EURO-2013-SLO-FRA

    Other NBA teams also watching Slovenia closely in World Cup to assess Zoran

  9. World Cup Preview: USA vs. Finland, what to expect

    Aug 30, 2014, 11:00 AM EDT

    Finland isn’t as good as the teams the USA was destroying in tune ups.

  10. Reports: Spurs making run at Ray Allen, who remains undecided if he will play anywhere

    Aug 30, 2014, 9:30 AM EDT

    2014 NBA Finals - Practice Day And Media Availability Getty Images

    He can decide this summer, or he can wait and join a team mid-season. There is no rush.

  11. James Harden on Kobe Bryant return: “He’s 20-year-old Kobe”

    Aug 30, 2014, 8:00 AM EDT

    Houston Rockets v Los Angeles Lakers Houston Rockets v Los Angeles Lakers

    “We talk and he’s ready. He’s 20-year-old Kobe. It’s going to be a crazy environment.” — James Harden on Kobe Bryant

  12. Record 45 current NBA players to compete in FIBA World Cup

    Aug 29, 2014, 11:15 PM EDT

    Pau Gasol and Marc Gasol (R) watch as th Getty Images

    Tournament features a record 75 players who have played in the NBA at some point, and we have the complete list.

  13. Chris Paul discusses his signature shoe, hoops with media at launch of his Jordan Brand CP3 VIII (VIDEO)

    Aug 29, 2014, 9:45 PM EDT

    101_Chris Paul Unveils Jordan CP3.VIII

    Chris Paul is way more into sneakers than you are, and articulated it well at the launch of his latest signature shoe in New York earlier this week.

  14. Report: Spurs interested in Mexico’s Gustavo Ayon

    Aug 29, 2014, 8:15 PM EDT

    ayon bucks Getty Images

    Ayon has played for four teams in three NBA seasons, and currently only has offers to play overseas next year.

  15. Iman Shumpert scares people (video)

    Aug 29, 2014, 4:15 PM EDT

    Iman Shumpert, Trevor Ariza Iman Shumpert, Trevor Ariza

    Knicks wing acts as security guard in prank

  16. 67RIEFNS No. 1: Tom Thibodeau managing his bigs

    Aug 29, 2014, 3:33 PM EDT

    Chicago Bulls v Los Angeles Lakers Getty Images

    Bulls have Joakim Noah, Pau Gasol, Taj Gibson and Nikola Mirotic

Featured video

Will LeBron get booed Christmas Day in Miami?
Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. D. Rose (2887)
  2. K. Love (2763)
  3. K. Bryant (2393)
  4. L. James (2282)
  5. C. Delfino (2163)
  1. T. Mozgov (2038)
  2. R. Allen (2014)
  3. K. Irving (1861)
  4. D. Waiters (1804)
  5. A. Davis (1769)