Skip to content

Who really deserves to start on the Knicks front line? Stoudemire, for sure. Randolph, no.

Oct 13, 2010, 1:37 PM EDT

arandolph_klove

Anthony Randolph was the Knicks big get in the David Lee trade — a 6’10” guy who can run the floor and play anywhere from the three to the five. A guy whose athleticism was bottled up by Don Nelson but was to be unleashed by Mike D’Antoni. He was going to explode past his 11.6 points and 6.5 rebounds per game as his minutes climbed in New York. He was going to make the Knicks front line dynamic.

So far, not so much. It’s just two preseason games but Randolph has looked inefficient and pedestrian enough that he will start the season coming off the bench, according to the New York Post.

So far this preseason (all of two games) Randolph has averaged 15 points and 3 rebounds per game, shooting 45.5 percent (which is right about what he shot in Golden State). His midrange shot he worked on a lot this summer has clanked around.

Randolph’s play — and Ronny Turiaf’s play and Timofey Mozgov’s play —  has left the Knicks with issues about who to play where along the front line.

D’Antoni wanted to play Amar’e Stoudemire exclusively at the power forward spot, but after a few weeks of camp Howard Beck of the New York Times told Knickerblogger that may have to change.

In Phoenix, the Suns were widely successful with Amar’e as their so-called undersized/non-traditional center, and I don’t know why the Knicks can’t be successful as well. I think they have to (try) a banger/traditional center next to Amar’e to help him out and keep him out of foul trouble. But I think there is a lot of merit of playing it the Suns way – which is go undersized at every position and just outrun the other team up and down the court. You know there are only a few true centers who are scoring centers in the league anyway, so it’s not as if Amar’e Stoudemire is going to just sit there every night and get banged on by low-post/back-you-down centers.

If D’Antoni starts Stoudemire at the four, and Danilo Galinari at the three, then who is the center?

Timofey Mozgov is going to get his chance, starting tonight, but coming out of the more physical play allowed in Europe and international ball he has been a foul sponge, soaking them up everywhere. Matched up against Shaq tonight will be a real test for him.

But he is the best fit because he can do the things the Knicks need — he can rebound, he can hit the midrange jumper to open up space for Stoudemire on the block, and he can block shots.

Randolph should be doing all those things, but right now Mozgov is doing them all better. Turiaf should be the energy guy off the bench wherever he goes. Wilson Chandler will come off the bench and be solid (but if you move Stoudemire to center he could start). But Randolph, you see where he could be more than that. Where he could be special.

But right now, Randolph is a bench guy.

Featured video

Wizards playing spoiler in East
Top 10 NBA Player Searches
  1. K. Durant (3020)
  2. D. Wade (2930)
  3. A. Jefferson (2888)
  4. D. Rose (2752)
  5. L. James (2617)
  1. J. Noah (2616)
  2. K. Bryant (2485)
  3. A. Bogut (2309)
  4. S. Curry (2167)
  5. N. Hilario (2135)